Home / Blog / How Great Leaders Handle Employees During Performance Reviews

How Great Leaders Handle Employees During Performance Reviews

6 min read

Charlie Kim, CEO at NextJump, asks a very good question on leadership.

While comparing leadership to parenting, he asks if your family is going through a hard time, will you lay off one of your children?

The answer to this is obviously no. Simon Sinek also talks about this in one of his TED talks on great leaders. If a child in a family comes home with a D, parents will most likely try their best to present him or her with opportunities to do better the next time and in the future.

However, this is not the case in businesses. If an employee does not have a satisfactory performance (which is mostly judged on the basis of unfair and subjective performance reviews), that employee has a higher likelihood of being laid off. Organizations that operate on such principles do not have great leaders.

Great leaders are people who are empathetic. These are the bosses who put the interest of their employees before them. It is never the number game for them. They put people before numbers and try their best to handle the situation accordingly. Such leaders are also good for businesses as they help earn more respect for themselves and the organization.

More and more employees voluntarily follow and admire them. If an organization plummets for any reason, great leaders ensure that they keep their employees safe and find a solution that is mutually agreeable to all.

Charlie Kim has set a great example in this regard. He introduced a lifetime employment policy at NextJump which states that an employee can never get fired because of performance issues. If at all there is a lack of optimal performance, that employee will be hand-held, guided, coached, and given all those opportunities that can help him become a better professional.

Recommended Read:- 35+ Best HR Books to Read in 2022

Key Is In The Hiring

The key here is to hire the right people so that organizations are sure from the very start about the potential of a candidate. Smart and thoughtful recruitment is extremely crucial and organizations need to do this better so that they are sure of who they are giving a chance to, from the very beginning.

When organizations take care of their employees to such an extent, they make them feel safe. And according to Simon Sinek, the natural response to feeling safe is to offer trust and cooperation. When your employees trust you as a leader, they will sail with you through the biggest crisis. This is because they believe in your cause and you as a changemaker.

On the other hand, if a leader is only listened to because of his authoritative position, employees will not admire or follow them because they want to, but because they have to. And doing anything with force never works in the long run. Genuine followership has to be organic. Such employees will eventually become unhappy and quit.

This is why when leaders lay people off or do not make their employees feel safe in an organizational environment, they are likely to get pissed off and leave. Employees are also constantly looking for a place where they can truly belong and make a difference. And they will do this under the leadership of a person who values people and their emotions.

They will stand by organizations whose leaders have won their trust over time by taking the right actions and displaying the right attitudes. Leaders need to provide an environment where every person is given the opportunity to learn and do remarkable things.

If there are performance issues with an employee, sit and talk to the person. A frank conversation about the changes in performance can reveal the true reasons behind it. Reasons can vary from personal problems to being overwhelmed with too much work or experiencing a sense of burnout.

Try and understand these issues first. There are also employees who might not be comfortable sharing their problems. This is why leaders need to step in and make a change. Re-engage such employees and provide the best you can to make them a whole lot happier, and ultimately, a whole lot productive.

In the same manner, leaders also recognize and award talent with top performance. They continuously inspire good behavior and show examples of being a great professional through their own attitude. It is only through great leaders that we can handle our employees better and retain them for long. They also coach managers to elicit the same behaviors so that leadership qualities trickle down the entire organization.

Table of Contents

    Meet the author

    Keka Editorial Team

    A bunch of inspired, creative and ambitious youngsters- that’s Keka’s editorial team for you. We have a thirst to learn new subjects and curate diverse pieces for our readers. Our deep understanding and knowledge of Human Resources has enabled us to answer almost every question pertaining to this department. If not seen finding ways to simplify the HR world, they can be found striking conversations with anyone and everyone , petting dogs, obsessing over gadgets, or baking cakes.


    Thank you for Subscribing!

    Related articles

    Employee Incentive Programs: Benefits, Examples and Best Practices
    Anwesha Panja 27 min read

    GenZ employees want more than a reward and recognition system, posing a challenge for HRs. Overcome this by exploring innovative incentive programs that go beyond the traditional rewards!

    Standing Out from the Crowd: How to Attract the Right Talent in a Competitive Market?
    Nikitha Joyce 19 min read

    Why do organizations look for talent in the same old, wrong places? While there is no best way, there are better approaches to attract talent in a competitive market. Explore how to define talent, attract, and develop strategies.

    Turning Appraisal Blues to Employee Happiness – Strategies for Post-Appraisal Management
    Nikitha Joyce 24 min read

    Appraisal seasons are both long-awaited and dreaded by both the employees and the company. However, employee discontent post-appraisal is inevitable. Find out the early signs of unhappiness and how to address such challenges.

    cookie image

    By clicking “Accept", you consent to our website's use of cookies to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. You may visit "cookie policy” to know more about cookies we use.